Heresy: definition
Heresy is the obstinate denial by a baptized person of a truth of faith that the Church teaches as revealed by God, or obstinate doubt about it. It differs from apostasy, which is the total abandonment of the Christian faith, and from schism, which is a break in communion.
A choice against the faith received
The word comes from the Greek hairesis, "choice": the heretic picks from the faith what suits him and rejects the rest. The Catechism defines it as "the obstinate post-baptismal denial of some truth which must be believed with divine and catholic faith, or it is likewise an obstinate doubt concerning the same."
So there must be a conscious and persistent refusal. Simple ignorance, an error made in good faith or a question one is asking oneself are not heresies. Church law provides for excommunication for formal heresy, in order to bring home the seriousness of the break and to call the person back.
Some great heresies
In the 4th century, Arianism denied that the Son is God equal to the Father; it was condemned at Nicaea in 325 and fought by bishops such as Saint Hilary of Poitiers. In the 5th century, Pelagianism claimed that man can save himself by his own strength; Saint Augustine answered it with the necessity of grace.
In the Middle Ages, Catharism set a good god against an evil god and despised the body. Saint Dominic founded the Order of Preachers to respond to it through preaching and poverty. In the 16th century, Saint Francis de Sales brought many inhabitants of the Chablais region back to Catholicism through patient preaching and leaflets slipped under doors.
Heresy and dialogue today
The Church distinguishes between the founders of a break and those who are born today into separated communities. The Catechism specifies that the latter cannot be charged with the sin of separation: the Church regards them as brothers and seeks unity with them, with respect for the truth. This is the meaning of ecumenical dialogue.
Saints to know
-
January 13 Saint Hilary of Poitiers
4th-century Bishop of Poitiers, defender of the faith of Nicaea against Arianism and Doctor of the Church
Exiled for fighting Arianism, he is nicknamed "the Athanasius of the West."
-
August 28 Saint Augustine of Hippo
bishop of Hippo, Father and Doctor of the Church, author of the Confessions
He fought Pelagianism and defended the necessity of grace.
-
August 8 Saint Dominic
Castilian priest, founder of the Order of Preachers, known as the Dominicans
He founded the Preachers to respond to the Cathar heresy through preaching.
-
January 24 Saint Francis de Sales
Bishop of Geneva, Doctor of the Church, author of the Introduction to the Devout Life and co-founder of the Visitation, patron saint of writers and journalists
He brought the Chablais back to Catholicism through gentleness and persuasion.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between heresy, schism and apostasy?
Heresy denies a specific truth of faith. Apostasy rejects the Christian faith as a whole. Schism refuses communion with the pope and the Church, without necessarily denying a truth of faith.
Are Protestants heretics?
The Church no longer calls them that: those who were born and raised in these communities did not choose a break. It regards them as separated Christian brothers and sisters.
Can you be excommunicated for heresy?
Yes: canon law provides for excommunication for formal, public and obstinate heresy. It can be lifted if the person returns to the faith of the Church.